The Weight of History: How U.S. Policy Toward Haiti Was Forged
The relationship between Haiti and the United States had never been one of equals. From the moment Haiti declared its independence in 1804, becoming the first Black republic in the world after a bloody revolution against French colonial rule, the U.S. regarded the fledgling nation with suspicion, if not outright hostility. Fearful that Haiti’s success would inspire enslaved people in America to revolt, the U.S. refused to recognize Haitian sovereignty for decades, while Southern lawmakers lobbied to isolate the island economically. This early antagonism set the tone for centuries of intervention, where American policy oscillated between neglect and manipulation, always prioritizing geopolitical interests over Haitian self-determination.
By the early 20th century, the U.S. had shifted from isolation to outright occupation. In 1915, under the guise of stabilizing Haiti’s political turmoil and protecting American business interests, U.S. Marines invaded and took control of the country’s finances, infrastructure, and government. For nineteen years, the occupation reinforced racial hierarchies, with white American officials overseeing forced labor campaigns that echoed Haiti’s colonial past. Though the Marines withdrew in 1934, they left behind a centralized military that would later become the tool of dictators—a legacy of instability that Washington would exploit during the Cold War.
When anti-communist paranoia swept U.S. foreign policy in the mid-20th century, Haiti’s fate was sealed. The U.S. backed the brutal Duvalier regime—first François “Papa Doc,” then his son Jean-Claude “Baby Doc,” turning a blind eye to their death squads and embezzlement so long as they kept Haiti from aligning with Cuba or the Soviet Union. American aid flowed to the Duvaliers, propping up their tyranny while ordinary Haitians suffered under repression and poverty. By the time the dictatorship crumbled in 1986, the country was hollowed out, its institutions corrupted, its economy gutted. And when Haiti finally attempted democracy with the election of Jean-Bertrand Aristide in 1990, the U.S. response was ambivalent at best. Though Washington initially supported his rise, it later acquiesced to his ouster—twice—leaving Haiti trapped in cycles of coups and foreign-backed interim governments.
Even humanitarian interventions carried the stain of exploitation. After the catastrophic 2010 earthquake, the U.S. mobilized aid but also reinforced militarized control, sending troops rather than prioritizing Haitian-led recovery. Later, United Nations peacekeepers introduced cholera into Haiti through negligent sanitation, sparking an epidemic that killed thousands—a disaster for which the UN refused full accountability. Meanwhile, American agricultural policies, from dumped subsidized rice to coercive trade deals, undercut Haitian farmers, deepening the nation’s dependence on foreign aid.
By the 21st century, these historical burdens manifested in U.S. immigration policies that treated Haitians as a problem to be contained rather than a people deserving refuge. Temporary Protected Status (TPS) was granted begrudgingly after disasters, then threatened with revocation under administrations more concerned with nativist rhetoric than justice. The Biden administration, caught between progressive promises and political pragmatism, expanded TPS for some while continuing deportations for others—leaving families as Mireille’s torn across borders.
And so, when gangs, armed with trafficked American weapons, overran Port-au-Prince, it was not merely a Haitian crisis. It was the inevitable outcome of decades in which U.S. policy had undermined Haiti’s sovereignty, sabotaged its institutions, and then punished its people for fleeing the chaos that foreign interference helped create. The cruelty was in the pattern: history had taught Haiti that American concern was always conditional, always self-interested. And for the thousands of Haitians living in limbo, their futures hinged on a nation that had yet to reckon with its role in their suffering.
Get your copy of Witness in the Dust by Lorrie C. Reed.
